Cleantech Blog "Power 10" Ranking Vol II 2009

Last year I did my first “Power 10” ranking for 2008 of cleantech companies, and the response was so good we’re doing it again.

I spend most of my day meeting and talking to companies in the cleantech sector. And those of you who know me know I have opinions on who is doing it right, and who is doing it wrong.

As before this is the Cleantech Blog Power 10 Ranking of cleantech companies doing it right.

Eligibility for inclusion in the ranking requires meeting a 6 point test. Suggestions for inclusions in future volumes are welcome. The 6 point test:
1. The company is energy or environmental technology related
2. I like their products
3. The market needs them
4. The company is smart about building their business
5. I’d like to own the company if I could (for the right price, of course!)
6. It is not already one of mine (my apologies to my friends Zenergy Power)

I have included cleantech companies big and small.

  1. Sharp – Makes the list again as top dog battling to hold its crown in solar PV. Keep on trucking.
  2. GE – Their M&A strategy delivered venture like returns, and they still hold power positions in wind, T&D, clean gensets, and water capital equipment. Hard to dethrone.
  3. Iberdrola – Barely didn’t make the cut last year. Largest wind operator in the world now. Deserves it.
  4. First Solar (NASDAQ:FSLR) – Still the low cost producer in PV and growing. Smart move swapping expensive stock for the Optisolar project pipeline. Keep those factories full!
  5. Goldman Sachs (NYSE:GS) -The only investor to merit consideration, but area a part of too many power plays in cleantech to leave off this time.
  6. DNV – Their auditors underpin roughly half of the carbon markets. In carbon, audit and verification is everything. Their market share slipped some, but they hold their crown as the only one of the big carbon auditors yet aggressively investing in the US.
  7. Applied Materials – The future of thin film if they can deliver on their strategic moves. But I need to see some of your customer’s production taking serious market share, or making next year’s list could be tough.
  8. Cleantech Group – The business is now definitely more than just a conference operator. Despite massive competition in conferences (long a cash cow for them), the Cleantech Group hasn’t lost its footing as the preeminent brand. And now seems to be learning how to play well with others. Great job guys on both creating an asset class AND building a cool company.
  9. Bayard Group/Landis Gyr – Smart grid is the big cleantech play along with carbon and solar. Bayard, now branded around Landis Gyr, is a global Metering/Smart Grid roll up powerhouse. Bought Cellnet, Hunt, Enermet, and Landis Gyr et al.
  10. Valero – Texas refiner’s acquisition of VeraSun and move into renewable fuels gets it the nod. Now where to from here?

Honorable mention to Zenergy Power plc (AIM: ZEN.L), one I helped cofound. I couldn’t resist this year since the team is making hay off of fault current limiter technology we bet on in 2004, and deserves the nod. Also to Smart Fuel Cell (XETRA:F3C.DE) – Still the most mature fuel cell company in the world by a mile. But revenues flattened in 2008 and it made no moves allowing it to stave off the newcomers to Power 10. 2009 is the make or break year. And finally to Sindicatum – Mover of the year in carbon in 2008. Raised a warchest into the teeth of a tough carbon market. Now we’ll see what they can do with it.

Also on our watchlist for next year: Abengoa, Acciona, SGS, Duke Energy, SoCal Edison, Origin Energy, Ecosecurities, Q-Cells, SunPower, Oerlikon, ConocoPhillips, BP, Shell.

Of note, no CIGS or solar thermal this year. The list is indicative of a shift towards carbon and projects. Still no cellulosic, and I can’t bring myself to add EVs to the Power 10 until somebody shows something real. Perhaps the 2013 list?

Neal Dikeman is a founding partner at Jane Capital Partners LLC, a boutique merchant bank advising strategic investors and startups in cleantech. He is founding contributor of Cleantech Blog, Chairman of Cleantech.org, and the Chairman of Carbonflow, Inc..

10 replies
  1. <a href="mailto:bkarney@aol.com?subject=SolarBuyersGroupQuestion">Bruce Karney</a>
    <a href="mailto:bkarney@aol.com?subject=SolarBuyersGroupQuestion">Bruce Karney</a> says:

    I would have thought that at least one solar installation or integration company, somewhere in the world, would have made the list.

  2. <a href="mailto:bkarney@aol.com?subject=SolarBuyersGroupQuestion">Bruce Karney</a>
    <a href="mailto:bkarney@aol.com?subject=SolarBuyersGroupQuestion">Bruce Karney</a> says:

    I would have thought that at least one solar installation or integration company, somewhere in the world, would have made the list.

  3. <a href="mailto:bkarney@aol.com?subject=SolarBuyersGroupQuestion">Bruce Karney</a>
    <a href="mailto:bkarney@aol.com?subject=SolarBuyersGroupQuestion">Bruce Karney</a> says:

    I would have thought that at least one solar installation or integration company, somewhere in the world, would have made the list.

  4. Neil Farbstein
    Neil Farbstein says:

    VULVOX breakthrough collectors will be able to generate electricity with 50% efficiency or greater. The dual solar thermal-photovoltaic system will wrest approximately twice as much power from an area as regular solar thermal or photovoltaic energy systems. Our technology can be used to retrofit existing parabolic troughs and solar power towers to increase their efficiency. Besides applications at utility scale solar power plants that are contributing electricity to the California power grid, they will also have an important advantage in the upcoming industry of rooftop solar power. Apartment buildings, skyscrapers and industrial buildings all have flat roofs that can accommodate our solar power systems and the greater efficiency of dual thermal-photovoltaic energy generation systems will make it cost competitive with other generation systems. The Vulvox collectors will not depend upon complicated advances in quantum or solid state physics. Our novel combination photovoltaic-solar thermal collectors will achieve the unprecedented efficiencies predicted here by means of relatively simple modifications to solar energy equipment; modifications that can be developed at a moderate cost. The Vulvox solar system will generate higher power levels than competing parabolic troughs and solar power towers, while retaining all of the storage capabilities of solar thermal power. Besides the inherent efficiency advantages of this collection system, we are sure we can add other modifications that will increase energy collection and electricity generation beyond those efficiencies. Modifications to increase the heat flow rate of the thermal collectors are an example. Every time a photovoltaic panel system is upgraded and increases in power we can substitute it for a lower power panels used in previous "builds." and the higher power panels can be used in upgraded combination PV-solar thermal collectors with higher efficiency. Also, every time solar thermal systems are upgraded they can be combined with the latest practical photovoltaic collectors to keep the next generation combination systems cost competitive and to keep their efficiency higher than all other collection systems. Contact us for more information .http://VULVOX.TRIPOD.COMPROTN7@ATT.NET

  5. growley@greenmileage
    growley@greenmileage says:

    Clean and green retrofits available on the market. This "Green Tech" company is looking for a licensee. Two third party lab tests show emission reductions and fuel mileage increases. Major Florida state University testing for diesel market feasibility. Gasoline injected engines has been proven with 3 years of Beta-Testing. Serious inquires can reply to growley@greenmileagemaker.com

  6. growley@greenmileagemaker.com
    growley@greenmileagemaker.com says:

    Clean and green retrofits available on the market. This “Green Tech” company is looking for a licensee. Two third party lab tests show emission reductions and fuel mileage increases. Major Florida state University testing for diesel market feasibility. Gasoline injected engines has been proven with 3 years of Beta-Testing. Serious inquires can reply to growley@greenmileagemaker.com

  7. Anonymous
    Anonymous says:

    I notice that you've been spammed by Neil Farbstein, so-called president of Vulvox.He has been claiming scientific breakthroughs for years, for everything including cold fusion, nanotechnology and genetic engineering. Yet a little checking shows that none of these breakthoughs exist.

  8. solar roof tiles
    solar roof tiles says:

    Great list, I imagine by 2012 you'll hopefully have to make a "Power 20" or a "Power 30" list as more and more companies embrace the alternative energy movement!

  9. Carl
    Carl says:

    The GREEN / Clean revolution is definitley gaining momentum. A friend of mine is even in the business of Eco-Friendly tableware made out of renewable sugarcane. Best Wishes to all the ground breaking companies listed here!

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!