The Thorny Nexus: Science and Religion and Politics and Climate Change

by Richard T. Stuebi

A fascinating article in Slate noted that 55% of scientists in the U.S. are Democrats, as opposed to 6% Republicans (with the remainder being independents or “don’t know”).  Since most Democrats favor action on climate change, so do most scientists. 

The implication, as the Slate article says:  “the results of climate science, delivered by scientists who are overwhelmingly Democratic, are used over a period of decades to advance a political agenda that happens to align precisely with the ideological preferences of Democrats.  Coincidence — or causation?”

The flip-side of this equation is religion.  Gallup has found that Republicans tend to be more religious than Democrats.  And, Republicans are generally more skeptical about the climate change phenomenon — (1) whether it’s happening at all, (2) even if so, whether human activity is causing it, and (3) even if so, whether it’s worth spending anything more than zero to do anything about it.

It also follows, then, that there is a negative correlation between religious belief and concern about climate change.  Put more simply, the more a person has religious faith, the less a person tends to worry about climate change.

If religious fervor can be quantitatively assessed, then it’s safe to say that evangelicals would get a high score, and it seems to be the case that evangelicals are especially adverse to the climate change issue.

As reported in the New York Times article “An Evangelical Backlash Against Environmentalism”, a non-profit evangelical organization called the Cornwall Alliance calls the environmental movement a “false religion”, and has issued an educational program titled “Resisting the Green Dragon” to warn Christians that the forces of radical environmentalism are seeking tyrannical control over all other beloved institutions such as God and country. 

To make matters more confusing, a court in England ruled in 2009 that a belief in climate change can be considered a religion in itself.

With respect to climate change, the “Evangelical Declaration on Global Warming” is well worth reading in its entirety to get a flavor of the position of the Cornwall Alliance.  It’s a far cry from the “creation-care” movement that other less-strident Christians have embraced, using theology as a foundation for planetary stewardship. 

It would appear that the ages-old schism between religion and science has therefore appropriated climate change as the newest issue over which to tangle.  Since the two U.S. political parties tend to cleave pretty neatly also alongside the science/religion divide, it makes the climate change debate particularly thorny and hard to untangle in either our churches or our legislatures, since strongly-held beliefs are always more emotionally powerful than facts.

5 replies
  1. malcolm g chapman
    malcolm g chapman says:

    If global warming was going to happen it should have happed in the late 18 19th century where everything was coal fired, trucks, shipping, factories, houses, so bad it blocked out the sun. the ice shelf melting yes it is in some areas, were even finding remanes of life and greenery is growing, in other areas acording to NOA its getting colder and thickening? the world is in a cycle, global warming is all about money, a democratic socialist plot backed by crying liberal democratic scientist.. Battery powered cars are a fad, they will not cure the environment or cost less to run, In the sumer we have brown outs due to all the air conditioning use, now imagin all those two million cars a year being produced and plugged in to the same system, your house electric bill will double causing more brown outs calling for more coal or oil burning power plants. Consumption of coal and oil has to end but it will not be overnight, useless windmills are an expensive old tech monstrosity that are unrelieable and prone to failure.

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. […] The Thorny Nexus: Science and Religion and Politics and Climate Change On January 24, 2011, in Blog, by Richard T. Stuebi by Richard T. Stuebi […]

  2. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Neal Dikeman, clean_tech_org. clean_tech_org said: 【Blog Comments】 Comment on The Thorny Nexus: Science and Religion and Politics and Climate Change by robert: th… http://bit.ly/gclTMr […]

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!